加载中...
加载中...
Assessment for Unit 6: Writing the Rhetorical Analysis Essay
Select the one best answer for each question.
1. The following questions are based on the passage below. **Prompt:** The following passage is an excerpt from a speech delivered in 2023 by Elena Vance, the Chairperson of the City Planning Committee, to a town hall meeting of residents from the Historic District. The residents have gathered to protest the city's proposal to demolish the 100-year-old Dyer Library to build a modern technology center. Read the passage carefully. Then write an essay that analyzes the rhetorical choices Vance uses to convey her message that the demolition is necessary for the community's future. **Passage:** 'Neighbors, I stand before you tonight not merely as a city official with a blueprint, but as a mother who taught her own children to read in the very stacks we discuss this evening. I feel the weight of every brick in the Old Dyer Library just as you do; the smell of the oak tables is woven into my own childhood memories. Yet, we must ask ourselves a difficult question: does the spirit of a community reside in the mortar of the past, or in the potential of our future? The structure is failing; the foundation cracks widen with every winter frost, and the wiring dates back to an era before the internet connected us to the world. To cling to the shell of this building is to deny our children the safety and the tools they deserve. We are not erasing history; we are building a stronger vessel to carry it forward.' Which of the following best describes the **exigence** of Vance’s speech within the rhetorical situation?
2. The following questions are based on a draft of a student's essay analyzing a speech delivered by community activist Elena Serra to the City Council regarding a proposed urban gardening initiative. Read the first paragraph of the student's draft: (1) In 2023, activist Elena Serra stood before the City Council to advocate for the 'Green Roots' initiative, a program designed to convert vacant lots into community gardens. (2) The council had previously rejected similar proposals due to budget concerns. (3) Serra’s speech uses a variety of rhetorical strategies to convince the council members to vote in favor of the initiative. (4) She talks about the health benefits of gardening, uses statistics about pollution, and tells a story about her grandmother. The student wants to revise sentence 4 to create a defensible thesis statement that establishes a clear line of reasoning for the essay. Which of the following versions of sentence 4 best accomplishes this goal?
3. The student is writing the second paragraph of the essay and wants to begin with a strong analytical claim that focuses on Serra’s use of comparison. Which of the following sentences best introduces the analysis of this rhetorical choice?
4. In the third paragraph, the student analyzes Serra’s appeal to the council’s authority. The student has written the following sentence: 'Serra mentions the council’s power to make changes.' The student wants to revise this sentence to better explain how this choice appeals to the audience’s values (ethos/pathos). Which revision best achieves this?
5. The student wants to ensure that the commentary in the fourth paragraph supports the thesis established in Question 1 (about the initiative being an investment). Read the draft sentence below: 'Therefore, the statistics Serra provides about reduced crime rates in green neighborhoods prove that the gardens are a good idea.' Which version of this sentence best refines the commentary to explicitly connect the evidence to the thesis regarding fiscal logic and investment?
6. The following questions are based on a draft of a student's essay analyzing a speech by environmental activist Marcus Thorne regarding the preservation of local wetlands. The writer wants to add a sentence after sentence 3 to provide specific textual evidence that supports the claim that Thorne uses logical appeals (logos) to counter the argument that development brings economic prosperity. Which choice best accomplishes this goal?
7. In sentence 8, the writer wants to integrate a direct quotation from Thorne's speech to maintain a smooth, academic flow and avoid a choppy sentence structure. Original Sentence 8: Thorne creates a feeling of shared responsibility. He says, "We are the stewards of this land, not its owners."
8. The writer wants to add a sentence to the end of the third paragraph (after sentence 12) to explain how the evidence quoted in sentence 12 supports Thorne’s overall purpose of conveying urgency. Sentence 12 quotes Thorne describing the wetlands as "vanishing at the speed of a breathless gasp." Which choice best provides this commentary?
9. The following questions are based on a student's draft of a rhetorical analysis essay. (1) In his essay 'The Decay of Conversation,' the author argues that digital interfaces have diminished our ability to engage in face-to-face discourse. (2) He begins by contrasting the sterile silence of a modern coffee shop, where patrons are glued to screens, with the boisterous noise of a 19th-century salon. (3) He describes the historical salon as a place of 'intellectual fencing' and 'spirited debate.' (4) This description helps the reader understand what a salon looked like in the past. (5) By juxtaposing these two environments, the author highlights the loss of communal engagement, aiming to evoke a sense of nostalgia and urgency in his contemporary audience to reclaim these lost social spaces. Which sentence in the passage is the best example of summary rather than rhetorical analysis?
10. The following is a draft of a student essay summarizing and analyzing the rhetorical strategies in John F. Kennedy’s 1961 Inaugural Address. (1) In his 1961 Inaugural Address, President John F. Kennedy addresses a nation facing the Cold War and significant global change. (2) He aims to unify the country and inspire citizens to participate in democracy. (3) Kennedy opens by using antithesis to highlight the contrast between the past and the future. (4) He notes that "Man holds in his mortal hands the power to abolish all forms of human poverty and all forms of human life." (5) This juxtaposition dramatizes the high stakes of the nuclear age. (6) Later, he employs chiasmus in the famous line, "Ask not what your country can do for you—ask what you can do for your country." (7) This structure flips the relationship between citizen and state, emphasizing responsibility. (8) Kennedy establishes his credibility, or ethos, early in the speech. (9) He refers to the "same solemn oath our forebears prescribed." (10) By connecting himself to the founding fathers, he makes himself seem more legitimate. (11) He knows that he is young and needs to prove he is up to the job. (12) The audience needs to trust him. (13) Finally, Kennedy uses metaphors to describe the world situation. (14) He talks about a "beachhead of cooperation" pushing back the "jungle of suspicion." (15) These images create a visual representation of the diplomatic struggles. (16) The speech was very successful and is still quoted today. The writer wants to change sentence 8 to better transition from the previous paragraph's focus on citizen responsibility to the new focus on Kennedy's authority. Which version of sentence 8 best accomplishes this goal?
11. The writer wants to replace sentence 16 with a statement that explains how the metaphors analyzed in the third paragraph contribute to Kennedy's overall purpose of unification identified in the introduction. Which version of sentence 16 best accomplishes this?
12. The following questions are based on a student’s draft of a body paragraph for a rhetorical analysis essay. The student is analyzing John F. Kennedy’s 1962 speech at Rice University regarding the nation's space effort. (1) Kennedy transitions to a discussion of the specific challenges of space exploration to shift the audience's perspective. (2) He lists technical difficulties such as heat, speed, and the unknown environment. (3) He states, "We choose to go to the moon in this decade and do the other things, not because they are easy, but because they are hard." (4) This famous quote shows his determination. (5) By admitting that the task is difficult, Kennedy makes the audience trust him more. (6) He wants the audience to support the funding for the space program. The writer wants to revise sentence 5 to improve the commentary by more precisely explaining how Kennedy’s rhetorical choice affects the audience. Which version of sentence 5 best accomplishes this goal?
13. The writer wants to combine sentences 3 and 4 to better integrate the textual evidence and strengthen the connection between the evidence and the analytical claim. Which version best achieves this?
14. The writer wants to revise sentence 6 to strengthen the line of reasoning by connecting the analysis of Kennedy's rhetorical strategy to his ultimate purpose. Which version of sentence 6 best achieves this?